Which Grow Lights are Best For Starting Seeds?

**This post may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you.

If you’ve ever stumbled into the world of grow lights, it can be like falling into the proverbial rabbit hole. Purple lights, white lights, LED, CFL, HID…it can be enough to make you want to just stick your seed trays in the window and hope for the best, am I right? 

I’ve been there …standing in the aisle, and squinting at box labels reading “lumens” “spectrum” and “PAR” and wonder if I was actually shopping for a physics experiment rather than a tomato seedling.

Here’s the good news: once you understand the main types of grow lights and how colors affect plant growth, the whole thing becomes way less intimidating. In this post, I’ll walk you through the options (past and present), explain how they differ, and share what’s actually worked for me when starting seeds indoors. By the end, you’ll know exactly which grow light setup makes the most sense for your seedlings — and your sanity.

Pin for Later

grow lights demystified

HID Lights: Talking Old School 

In the past, grow lights were exclusively HID (High Intensity Discharge ) and used in commercial growing settings. The bulbs that went into these lights was powered by xenon gas that traveled between 2 electrodes from one end to the other. The light produced was very much reminiscent of natural sunlight. These bulbs were used to power other mechanisms, too, like car headlights.

Periodically, they had to be changed and required careful handling as fingerprints and natural skin oils could degrade the light quality.

There are two main types of HIDs – there’s the HPS – (High Pressure Sodium) which emit light in the reddish/orange spectrum, that supports the fruit-producing plant stage. The other is in the blue spectrum , known as MH (Metal Halide) and used more in the early stages of growth – responsible for producing strong roots and growth of foliage.

LEDs: Modern and Popular 

HIDs have gradually been fazed out (although there are some people who still use them today!) Now they are supplanted by the highly popular LEDs which are universally in most contemporary light setups. LED stands for Light Emitting Diode and work very differently from bulbs – diodes are actually chips that are arranged on a circuit board. Although they have a narrow color range, they emit light from different points, but when arranged together they can appear to be any color.

HIDs are different in that the light all comes form one source.

This is what the underside of one of my LED grow lights look like. Notice how the little squares look white and red, but they are purple when switched on!

led strip lights

One reason LED lights are preferred by gardeners over the old-school HIDs is the fact that they are cooler to the touch. This is true of LEDs in general, not just grow lights..You may have noticed this with the newer models of holiday lighting!  So there’s that – HID lights get fairly hot, so they need to be elevated above plant rows by at least 18″.

If plants’ foliage gets hot along with cold roots, it could lead to a lot of stressed-out vegetation. Therefore, to this day, HID lights make sense in colder environments only. The second thing is the fact that LED lights are more energy efficient.

CFL Lights: The Midrange Option

Are there other types of light used in gardening nurseries? Yes. There is a third main type that is popular on the market today, and that’s the CFL (compact fluorescent lighting) Instead of the well-known long tube they are in the bulb shape you may be familiar with for everyday use. Long fluorescent tubes are not only cumbersome to deal with, they are fragile, God help you if one of them shatters.

They emit light that meets the criteria of optimum PAR spectra (I’ll explain what that means shortly.) They have replaced incandescent lights in efficiency and output. 

Ideally, look for “full spectrum” when it comes to good lights. “Lumens” is the metric used on LED lights and refers to strength of light visible to the human eye but it doesn’t tell you exactly what is usable by plants, which is where the PAR metric comes in.

How Colors Of Light Affect Plant Growth

On with that, now let’s talk about the different colors on the spectrum and how they are influential in plant growth.

You may or may not be familiar with color spectrums, wavelengths, the color prism, etc…all related to science. If not that’s OK too. We’ll focus on how this science relates to plant life. There is a scale known as the PAR (Photosynthetic Active Radiation) which is a metric of light on the spectrum including wavelengths measured in NM (nanometers.)

color spectrum graph

The most abundant phase of plant growth is encompassed by the 400-700 NM range. Light wavelengths that fall outside of this spectrum still have value, but figure less prominently. Red is on the highest end (the 700) and the color that is responsible for the most fruit producing (Blue) is on the 400 range end. So you might say blue is the growth color.

Green factors in the least –  after all, chlorophyll is the green pigment that plants have in abundance, so all it does is reflect it back.

White, on average, is good….I have 2 white LED bulbs with the standard socket in my grow room and 2 more in the living room for my houseplants to supplement them through the wintertime. The latter, of course, being decorative, I do not have any other goals for them other than to stay healthy. 

But for immature seed starts, I’d say blue is the best choice, at least initially. Of course, the lights I use for them are purple, combining both the red/blue spectra.

Bulbs, Multi-Arm, Hanging and Strips: Choosing a Style

Grow Lights also come in different styles: Bulbs , Multi-Arn, Hanging Mount and strip lights.

purple grow lights

I like the strip lights as you can versatile options to affix them with: double sided tape, use hardware or zip ties -which is what I did since the only way to do so with the shelving I have was through one of the open spaces.

Bulbs can be installed anywhere you have a “normal” 40-60 watt socket. They tend to work best for smaller, more contained environments (like my small closet) and for maintain healthy light outputs on the dreary winter days, which is great for houseplants. For my seedlings on the top shelf, one bulb produces a good output, but the ones in the lower shelves need the strip lights to flourish.

lighting for starting seeds

Hanging Mounted lights are a little more bulky and intended to be mounted overhead, sometimes they are suspended from chains. They typically involve some hardware and tools to install. They can be adjusted and repositioned to be more favorable for growth as needed.

Multi- Arm lights are kind of a new design… They remind of of those 70s style floor lamps with the tiered multiple globes. Each light (usually about 3) is on a different swivel than the others and allows you to reposition them a la carte to different plants. 

If you have multiple pots with different plants that may have varying lighting needs, that could be the ideal way to go. I’m not entirely sure about their longevity, though. However, I love the design and concept!

FAQs About Grow Lights for Seedlings

Do regular LED bulbs work for seedlings?

Not really. Regular household LEDs are designed to please your eyes, not your plants. They usually don’t put out enough of the blue and red spectrum that seedlings need to grow strong and healthy. You’ll have much better success with bulbs labeled “full spectrum” or specifically made for plant growth.

How long should grow lights be on each day?

Most seedlings thrive with 12–16 hours of light daily. A simple plug-in timer is a lifesaver here — no need to remember to flip the switch every morning and night.

How close should grow lights be to seedlings?

It depends on the type of light, but a good rule of thumb is 2–4 inches above seedlings for LEDs and CFLs. HID lights should stay much farther away (12–18 inches) because they put out a lot more heat. Watch your plants — if the leaves look scorched or are stretching too tall, adjust accordingly.

Do seedlings need complete darkness at night?

Yes! Just like us, plants need a rest period. Darkness lets them switch gears from photosynthesis into other important growth processes. Stick with a day/night cycle, and your seedlings will be happier.

Can I mix different types of grow lights?

You can — some gardeners combine white LEDs with red/blue strips for balance. But honestly, most beginners do just fine with a single set of full-spectrum LEDs. Keep it simple until you feel like experimenting.

What’s the difference between “lumens” and “PAR”?

“Lumens” measure brightness as humans see it. “PAR” (Photosynthetically Active Radiation) measures the wavelengths plants actually use for photosynthesis. When shopping for grow lights, PAR is more important than lumens, though many companies advertise both.

So, Which Grow Light Should You Choose for Seedlings?

At the end of the day, the best grow light for starting seeds is usually an LED full-spectrum light. They’re energy efficient, stay cool to the touch (no scorched spinach starts, thank you very much), and they cover both the blue and red ranges that seedlings crave. If you’re just starting out, a simple LED strip or bulb setup will do the job beautifully.

That said, CFLs are still a solid budget-friendly option if you only have a tray or two, and HID lights still have a place for large-scale growers or chilly basements. But for most home gardeners? LEDs are hands-down the sweet spot.

The main thing is this: don’t overthink it. Your seedlings need consistent light, the right spectrum, and enough hours each day. Beyond that, it’s all about what fits your space and comfort level. Once you get those little sprouts thriving under the glow of their “mini sun,” you’ll wonder why you ever stressed about watts and lumens in the first place.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *